SituationAn 84 year old woman was readmitted to Royal Perth Hospital on the 3/7/2010 after a failed discharge on the 1/7/2010. The patient had been admitted originally for pneumonia and after a week in a general medical ward she was transferred to the short-term rehabilitation ward. On discharge services were organised for the patient; RITH for physiotherapy and occupational therapy and Silver Chain for meals, shopping and showering services, as the patients mobility and ability to perform her activities of daily living had declined in the weeks prior to and during her admission.
When the RITH physiotherapist arrived at the patient’s home for the second treatment session, the patient had been sitting on her four-wheeled walker for four hours, too afraid to get up as she feared the brakes were not working and she may lose her balance. The therapist helped the patient to her feet, but she refused to walk any further than the dining room table 3 metres away. On discussion with the patient the therapist also found that the patient had not been eating regularly, had mobilized minimally and had not been taking care of her indwelling catheter. As there were no services organised for the weekend and the patient’s family were unavailable to assist, the therapist organised for the patient to be readmitted for more suitable discharge planning.
Task
My task was to assess the patient and treat accordingly, keeping in mind that her discharge planning was an important aspect of her readmission.
ActionOn assessment of the patient she appeared to be slightly confused and frustrated with why I was there. I had explained to her that I was a physiotherapy student, there to have look at her chest and how she was moving and if necessary to treat her and give her some tools in order to help her get home as soon as possible. The patient kept asking questions such as “Why do you need to know if I have a cough? Of course I have a cough, I have a chest infection”. While I kept explaining that I needed to have an understanding of what she was experiencing in order to help her, she still seemed to lack understanding. She did however have an understanding of why she was there and have a good grasp of her situation. All in all it was a difficult subjective assessment and it felt as though I was continually justifying my presence.
The patient appeared much calmer on objective assessment and it went smoothly until I asked her to get up so that we could go for a walk. Initially the patient refused to stand at all, but with some encouragement and assistance she did. However, after about 20 seconds the patient insisted on sitting back down. I asked the patient why she needed to sit down and she refused to answer me or even look in my direction. I explained that in order for me to help her she needed to tell me what was wrong. Again, the patient ignored me. On my third attempt to mobilize the patient I explained that I understood that she might be nervous of standing but I would be there to assist her and that if she wanted to return home she would need to be able to walk. Finally the patient responded, stating that she just couldn’t walk, that she didn’t know why and that there was nothing I could do to help, as it was all her responsibility to start walking again. I asked a few more times what was stopping her from walking, suggesting things such as leg weakness, anxiety, fear, breathlessness or pain but she stated no to all options. I reasoned that it was most likely anxiety as she had stated that she was too nervous to stand from her four-wheeled walker at home due to fear of falling and she appeared to be a proud person, wanting to maintain that there was nothing wrong with her. I asked her if she would consider walking if I brought in a strong male to assist her to walk and she nodded, saying that she might consider it after lunch.
I found a time that suited my supervisor that afternoon and together we went back to see the patient. My supervisor just acted as a physiotherapy assistant and with his appearance as a strong male the patient ambulated approximately 12 metres without any complaints.
ResultsAs a result of my treatment the patient ambulated 12 metres with one person assisting the first day, 30 metres with stand-by assistance the second day and 50m with stand-by assistance the third day. The patient has also been accepted into transitional care for 8 weeks with permanent low-level care following that.
The patient also apologised for her reaction to me at our first meeting, stating that she had so many weeks of people asking her questions that she was unsure where they were all from and why they all couldn’t communicate the information between each other.
EvaluationThe importance of explaining who you are and what you are there for has really become clear to me. Patients in acute medical wards are constantly being bombarded with different staff wanting different pieces of information and explaining very little to them. I have witnessed countless medical teams and nursing staff just waltz into a patient’s room, ask them questions, test multiple things, discuss the patient without including them in the conversation and walk straight out. It leaves the patient anxious and confused about their medical treatment and the path that they will be taking. As physiotherapists we have the skills and the training to offer our patients superior communication skills and the time to give them explanations regarding their treatment and the direction that they will be taking.
We also have the skills and time to really evaluate our patients from an angle other than their blood test results and their ability to mobilize. It is our ability to really listen to what they are saying and look at their body language to assess what is really going on. If I had just listened to this patient without taking in all of the information available I never would have realized that she was just really anxious about mobilizing and I could have mistaken her anxiety and frustration for confusion.
Strategies
As a physiotherapist we should always take the time to really listen to our patients. Not just to what they are saying directly in answer to our questions but also to what they are saying outside of the context of the question. It is also important to read their non-verbal communication and gauge their reactions to certain situations. An entire picture of a patient is required to treat them effectively and that takes superior communication skills.